Islamic House of Cards
The 3 Pillars That Hold Up Islam — and Why Pulling Just One Collapses the Whole Structure
📘 Introduction
Islam is built on a three-legged stool:
-
The Book — the Quran
-
The Man — Muhammad
-
The Law — Sharia
Muslims claim: “Perfect book, perfect prophet, perfect system.”
But the truth is: Remove one leg, and the whole thing crashes.
This post shows how each pillar is critical, and how every one of them fails under scrutiny — historically, theologically, and logically.
📖 1. THE BOOK — The Quran
What Muslims Claim:
-
The eternal, unchanged word of Allah
-
Free from contradiction
-
Scientifically miraculous
-
Linguistically unmatched
-
Protected by divine preservation
Why It Fails:
-
Contradictions abound: creation timeline (6 vs. 8 days), Jesus’ death (dead or not?), free will vs. predestination
-
Scientific errors: semen from backbone/ribs, sun setting in muddy spring, stars as missiles
-
Textual corruption: Uthman burned variants, Sana’a manuscripts show edits
-
Variant Qurans: Hafs ≠ Warsh ≠ Qalun ≠ Duri
-
Requires human tafsir: “clear book” needs 1,000+ years of interpretation?
📌 Remove the Quran’s divine status — and Islam has no foundation left.
👤 2. THE MAN — Muhammad
What Muslims Claim:
-
The final, sinless prophet
-
Moral example for all time
-
Illiterate man delivering the Quran proves miracle
-
Foretold in previous scriptures
-
The “seal” of all prophecy
Why It Fails:
-
Moral failings: married a 6-year-old, kept sex slaves, ordered assassinations, raided caravans
-
Political convenience: revelations aligned with his desires (33:37), immunity (5:67), privilege
-
No miracles: even the Quran denies signs when requested (6:37, 17:90–93)
-
Not foretold in Bible: no trace of a “prophet Ahmad”
-
Historically obscure: no non-Islamic sources confirm his life for over a century
📌 Remove Muhammad’s credibility — and Islam’s entire narrative dies with him.
⚖️ 3. THE LAW — Sharia
What Muslims Claim:
-
Complete system for all of life
-
Just, fair, divine
-
Better than man-made laws
-
Unchanging truth
-
Solution for the modern world
Why It Fails:
-
Human-constructed: based on hadith compiled 200 years later
-
Contradictory schools: Hanafi ≠ Shafi’i ≠ Hanbali ≠ Maliki
-
Morally bankrupt: permits slavery, wife beating, child marriage, death for apostasy
-
Gender inequality: 2:282, 4:11–12, 4:34 — built-in male supremacy
-
Violently enforced: blasphemy, hudud punishments, vigilante mobs
📌 Remove Sharia’s divine claim — and Islam becomes just another flawed human legal system.
🧨 The Collapse
| Pillar | Claimed to Be | In Reality |
|---|---|---|
| 📖 Quran | Perfect, unaltered, divine | Contradictory, edited, incoherent |
| 👤 Muhammad | Morally pure, final prophet | Ethically flawed, politically motivated |
| ⚖️ Sharia | Just, divine law | Oppressive, man-made, contradictory |
Islam depends on all three standing.
Break one — the others fall.
And all three? Already broken.
✅ Final Word
Islam sells itself as a complete package.
But like a house of cards — it only looks solid until you touch it.
Book, Man, Law.
Remove any one…
Islam falls.
No comments:
Post a Comment