Exposing Islam

What If the Quran Is Wrong?

A Thought Experiment Muslims Fear to Take

📘 Introduction

“This is the Book in which there is no doubt…” — Quran 2:2

Islam doesn’t tolerate grey zones. The Quran is either:

Absolutely true, or
Completely false.

But real truth — doesn’t fear questions.

So let’s ask the one question that Muslims are trained never to ask:

❓ What if the Quran is wrong?

🚪 Thought Experiment Rules

Let’s suspend belief — just temporarily.
No apologetics. No “context.” No “you’re not a scholar.”
Just an honest thought experiment:

🧪 “Assume the Quran is not from Allah. What would we expect to find?”

🔎 What Should a Divine Book Look Like?

If a book is from an all-knowing, all-powerful Creator, it should meet objective, universal standards. It should:

Be free from contradiction
Be morally flawless
Transcend time, place, and culture
Be scientifically accurate
Be historically verifiable
Be intellectually coherent
And crucially: adhere to the laws of logic and contain no logical fallacies

📌 That means:

❌ No circular reasoning — e.g. “The Quran is true because it says so”
❌ No false dilemmas — e.g. “Either you’re a believer or arrogant”
❌ No special pleading — e.g. “You need to know Arabic”
❌ No affirming the consequent — e.g. “It’s beautiful, so it must be divine”
❌ No equivocation, vagueness, or ambiguity to mask contradictions

If a philosophy undergrad can spot the fallacies — it's not from an eternal Mind.

❌ 1. Contradictions Are Everywhere

“If it had been from other than Allah, you would have found many contradictions in it.” — Quran 4:82

And we do:

6 vs. 8 days of creation
Jesus: died or not?
Pharaoh: drowned or saved?
Torah & Gospel: preserved or corrupted?
Free will vs. divine control

👉 By its own standard — the Quran is false.

❌ 2. Science? Dead on Arrival.

Semen from between ribs and backbone (86:6–7)
Sun sets in a muddy spring (18:86)
Stars are missiles to chase devils (67:5)
Embryology: “clot of blood”?
Earth spread out like a carpet (88:20)

These aren’t divine insights — they’re 7th-century superstitions.

❌ 3. Morality? Not Divine.

Child marriage modeled by Muhammad
Beating wives allowed (4:34)
Slavery and concubinage permitted
Death for apostasy and blasphemy
Eternal Hell for finite disbelief

A divine moral system should surpass tribal ethics — not replicate them.

❌ 4. History? Full of Errors.

Mary (mother of Jesus) confused with Miriam (sister of Aaron)
No external evidence of Mecca’s religious status pre-Islam
Quran borrows from Gnostic gospels, Jewish folklore, and apocrypha
Earliest Qurans show corrections, not perfection
Hadiths admit verses lost, eaten, forgotten, or abrogated

❌ 5. The Author Looks Human

Convenient revelations to justify Muhammad’s desires (33:37, 66:1)
No real prophecies or verifiable miracles
Frequent use of threats over reason: “Believe or burn”
Language full of pride, vengeance, and conditional mercy
Personal grievances (e.g., against Abu Lahab) included in the “eternal word of God”?

📌 These are human fingerprints — not divine ones.

🧠 The Risk of Asking

Muslims are told that even questioning the Quran is dangerous.
Because if the Quran isn’t from Allah… then:

Muhammad isn’t a prophet
Sharia isn’t divine
Islam isn’t true
And everything changes

But fear of the answer is not the same as truth.

🔓 What If It Is Wrong?

Then:

Billions are trapped in an illusion
Truth is being censored, not discovered
Apostates aren’t “rebels” — they’re honest thinkers
And you have the right to question — without guilt, shame, or fear

✅ Final Word

This isn’t hate. This is courage.

“If it’s true, it will survive your questions.
If it’s false, it deserves them.”

So ask the forbidden question: